I'm still kinda not sold on this game, to tell the truth. Definitely waiting on a price drop.
Don't take anything I say as a genuine attack on the game, because I'm just speaking of my personal preferences as well as some things I've noticed about the game which may be completely off and of my imagination entirely. I'm also very open to changing my mind here, because I've been hearing very mixed opinions from different people who's tastes I generally trust.
I know you can say "it captures the core reading focused style of fighting games with only 2 moves!", but I feel that the very fact that it pairs down fighting game mechanics so much is a point against it (for me at least). One of the things I love about fighting games are the vast number of options, the movement, the freedom to come up with your own play style, the fact that it has infinite depth but you're actually fighting and not just moving pieces on a board. If I wanted to play a fighting game without movement and with only 2 moves...I would just not play fighting games lol.
Also one of my favorite things in any genre of game is freedom of mobility. A sense of movement is very important to me.
My other issue, and one that has kept one of my friends away from the game as well, is that it looks very "random". The simplicity, small number of options, and ultra fast nature of the game seems to make a lot of choices less weighty, so it becomes a lot harder to read opponents. I see a lot of good, smart players seem to get "randomed out" constantly. And furthermore, a lot of my friends who DID get ultra enthusiastic about the game at launch, dropped it nearly a weak later due to a seeming lack of depth and staying power.
It seems to me like a fun game to watch, and a decent party game to crack out once in a while, but I don't see it going much beyond that. Am I wrong here?