Wow... How in the hell is it that I disagree with both spencer and the people that disagree with him?
Jeez.
Spencer is correct in his primary assertion that assists give plus frames on offense and zero one move startup on defense. But that's where he stops being correct.
The detractors are correct in that with both teams having the same options, things balance out and are fair (depending on teams of course) And that's where basically everyone stops being correct.
Everything else is cherry picked examples that only pertain slightly to what an assist is as they are in SG or even in marvel.
Sure assists give mucho plus frames to do mixups and sure that thing doesn't really happen in non striker games. But it does happen. In GG as the biggest example many characters can use projectiles as strikers... But the caveat is that they don't USUALLY get the setup for free or even easily whereas striker games you do tend to get these setups very easily and with no startup or recovery as well.
Even most puppet characters have some form of startup or meter management to be aware of and manage whereas assists can Just be called willy nilly for the most part.
So...I see both arguments being right in certain aspects and I see both arguments being wrong in certain aspects.
@Spencer
We've talked about this plenty of times now, but I still don't see how you can think that playing the neutral is simply hiding behind your assists in assist games, whereas in non assist games you can't see that players hide behind other things.. such as fireballs and dps and long range normals etc etc.
I mean I do see that assists certainly fundamentally change the game at neutral and that assists have less risk to throwing out than say throwing a fireball in jumpin range in streetfighter, but assists still have risks such as them taking huge damage via smart counter calls as well as being assistless for a good amount of time should you wiff them etc.
I understand you just not liking that type of play, cause that is exactly what I DO like about SG... Being able to be so free with my offense and having so many more options to do things that I'm simply not used to being able to do in any other fighter... It's like being able to fly for real when you have a streetfighter background such as myself.
But I guess where i see nothing but freedom you see nothing but restrictions. Funny that thing called perspective, funny indeed.