Christ that dude is a massive tool. I just want to punch him in his stupid monochrome face, regardless of his opinions.
Everyone wants to harp on Sony for their biggest release being a remake, or their overuse of CGI trailers, which seems to suggest they didn't actually watch the conference.
Horizon was a new IP presented with actual gameplay, No Man's Sky, while we knew about it already, is a new IP presented with actual gameplay, The Last Guardian, even though it clearly takes some design elements from SotC and ICO, is very clearly a unique IP that was presented with gameplay, even the kinda generic Dream was a new IP presented with actual gameplay.
Uncharted 4 had gameplay, the new Final Fantasy spin-off which was presented along with the remake was presented with gameplay, Street Fighter V and Destiny, while by no means original ideas, were presented with gameplay.
But,
I guess because these remakes and sequels exist and people are excited for them, the industry must be dying, that's what it is you pretentious sunglass-wearing douchebag.