The difference between Painwheel and Shockbrave is that one is recognizable as an actual pun while the other sounds more like combination of two words that sound cool. When I first heard Shockbrave I didn't think "Oh that's a pretty good pun on the word Shockwave", what I thought was "What is this guy trying to do with a name like that?" Basically if you're going to use a pun name then make sure it actually sounds like a pun.
There's no way to say this nicely so I'll just say it. As names Painwheel and Parasoul are much better than Shockbrave and the fact that you think otherwise confounds me.
Also when it comes to real names you really shouldn't be worrying about other characters having the same name. There are only so many names in the world and they're all taken, so you might as well stop worrying about it.
In fact I'm willing to bet that there is a bad Sonic OC out there who already has the name Shockbrave.
I'm not telling you to change that name, I'm just telling you what I think, which is that it's not good.
Sorry.
Denizen said:
As names Painwheel and Parasoul are much better than Shockbrave and the fact that you think otherwise confounds me.
Well that's your opinion, not a fact. Not to be rude, but next you shouldn't make it sound like a statement, just saying. And again, I still disagree with you. I get what you meant by that they should sound like pun, but in my own opinion you forgot the
other difference between these names:
From my story written about her, it shouldn't be hard to see why my OC got the name that she did if you read it: Has electric shocking powers and a brave personality. Painwheel, while I don't like the name too much, also has a reason for her name: She has a sawbuzz pinwheel weapon that will make you weep with pain and blood if she decides to use it on you.
Now Parasoul on the other hand.. I fully understand the
para and the fact that she's named after an umbrella. What I don't get is the
soul part.
- Can she talk to ghosts and dead people from beyond the grave? Never seen her do it or hear the canon mention it, so I'm gonna assume not.
- Can she summon the undead like Bloody Marie can (but with ghosts instead of skeletons)? No.
- Is she a ghost herself? Still no.
- Does she eat and devour the souls of others? I heavily doubt that.
What I'm basically saying is: Even though she has the word in her name, what does this Jessica Rabbit look-alike have to do with souls? Correct me if I'm wrong, but apparently the answer to that is: Nothing. You might say otherwise and it may not bother you, but to me: it just seems really pointless to make someone's name a pun when that someone his/herself has almost nothing to do with the one of the words that formed the pun in the first place. If the name belonged to someone that pertains to both umbrellas and souls at the same time, it would be a good name. But the ugly truth is, its not.. at least in my opinion it isn't. I feel that Parasoul didn't even need a pun name to begin with (or at least not
this one) because of it, and that
she's the one who could've just gotten a normal name. Even if my OC's name isn't good, at least it's got a reason for the pun on both words; where Parasoul's character has only partial reference to her own name and I feel that the 2nd part of the compound word was added only because is its a homophone of "sol" and they
had to make it a pun at all for some anonymous reason... nothing more.
Denizen said:
There are only so many names in the world and they're all taken, so you might as well stop worrying about it.
In fact I'm willing to bet that there is a bad Sonic OC out there who already has the name Shockbrave.
You're right, but that's why you gotta take that name
before other people while you still can (which in my case, consider me lucky). A lot of people have real names and a lot of people use them in fan fiction, but not everyone is going to go after the same made-up name. Even if some people already made SB as a name, I'm sure that they are extremely scarce and not really noticeable, though admittedly you could say the same thing about my OC. In fact, I've only found one other person use this name (which was
after I used mine), which has nothing to do with fictional characters and is merely just someone's name on a (Seemingly) unpopular online game with only 9 players online.
And even with a lame name, that doesn't change that the rest (okay, most of it) of my character is pretty good so far, right? Right? I don't mean to toot my own horn, but I'm rather pleased with how Shock's currently turning out and for a first-timer making an FC, I don't think I'm doing too bad. I liked her so much that I even forgot about the other 2 OCs (and others to come) I made, making them look a little worthless in her light. If Lab Zero Games were to ever make fan contest to submit their fanmade characters, I would without a doubt submit Shockbrave and would hope to get at least a small honorable mention from them, even if I knew I had a 0% chance of the slightest bit of success. The only reason I wouldn't is because I'm a terrible artist and couldn't draw a good picture of her. Even then, I would just try to get help from good artists and do it before its over.
I know something like that would probably never happen, but a guy can dream. Adventure Time had an episode with a fanmade character..