I'm with you Balder, the world of Drangleic is lacking in comparison to Lordran, on top of a fair number of the bosses being unchallenging or boring from a design standpoint. The game is still great, and pve is better than the original for the most part, but it's just missing a lot of charm.
I feel the inevitable comparisons with DS1 is one of the reasons. You see a character and think "oh this is this game's X", like Creighton feeling like a Lautrec expy. There's also some missed opportunities with great characters that have very little dialogue; Licia of Lindelt is the best example - she's basically Rhea+Petrus+Lautrec but she only has two moments and while you can quickly tell she's up to no good, nothing about her makes her out to be anything besides a charlatan.
I think Drangleic is missing people that are as relatable/likable as those in Lordran (folks like Gough, Siegmeyer and Laurentius), as most here come off as being crazy, asshole or a crazy asshole. Nonetheless, there's still a lot of characters I like, my favorites being:
Benhart of Jugo - he's the bro character, how can you not like him? Also love his voice.
Straid of Olaphis - DAT GLORIOUS HAM!
Feeble cursed one! Do you really think you can manage the glories that are my spells?
Head of Vengarl - the conversation with him was the first moment DS2 truly hit me in the feels.
Why must life be so confounding?
Shalquoir - that cheeky pussy! nyan nyan :3
Ornifex - for a Painted World crow, very cool gal. I love how she says "Haters gonna hate.
" in the most poetic fashion.
Mild-mannered Pate - for a Patches expy, he's a surprisingly trustworthy guy. Amazing VA, but this could be said of everyone, really.
Dyna & Tillo -
Yah yah. So nice, so smooth. Yah yah! Silky smooth! (I love these two. Their voices genuinely make me laugh. Fuck the haters.)
Special mention to Lonesome Gavlan but he's not a character so much as he's a meme.
As for bosses and enemies, I wish bosses had more build-up and/or were more creative. Also way too many ganker bosses.
A big disappointment is Mytha as there seems to be a lot of lore about her but the area has nothing to do with her and when you do face her, it's Medusa and no explanation why her head is off the shoulders. Area needed statues, broken mirrors and things that say "this is the dwelling of a vain woman who lost her shit".
Other bosses like Smelt It Demon, Iron King and Skeleton Lords just come off as Diablo rejects.
I think Freja and The Rotten are good examples of the areas creating a very good build up towards the boss fight.
And as for enemies, I think there's too many infantry and knights. The bestiary ends up feeling a little limited.
I have yet to get DS2, but please tell me theres SOME kind of Solaire equivalent in this game! I need a bro to partake in Jolly Cooperation!
Benhart of Jugo is Solaire's spiritual successor. He's a warrior who made his way to Drangleic in order to hone his skills, is very friendly to the player, can be summoned for 4 boss fights (including the end boss!) and you can make a bro pun with his name - BROHART!
A friend just told me that you need to reach rank two in the Bell Keeper covenant to get all of the spells in the game.... crap, now I have to learn how to fight other players....
There are three scrolls that require Covenant rank:
[Miracle] Sunlight Spear - Rank 3 Sunbro
[Spell] Hidden Weapon - Rank 2 Bellbro
[Hex] Climax - Rank 3 Pilgrims of Dark
All other covenant spells can be bought from Chancellor Wellager. All in all, these 3 aren't the worst. Pilgrims is PvE, Sunbros is jolly cooperation and with Bellbros you can gank and have lag on your side.
I wish there were more Soul Greatswords in the game, it's my favorite spell and I could really use more than 3 uses.
Buy Amber Herbs from Ornifex. She sells a unlimited supply after beating the end boss.