• As part of the relaunch of Skullheart, ALL previous threads have been archived. You can find them at the bottom of the forum in the Archives (2021) section. The archives are locked, so please use the new forum sections to create new discussion threads.

The Unofficial Official Beta Discussion Thread

Also, can we do something about Cerebella's anchor point being so far below her hurtbox? At least during combos? Why does it need to be at the tip of her knives instead of her foot and the tip of her hons instead of her head?
This. For the love of god, this


I would post the comparison images with other characters' anchor point, but I'm not near my computer atm since I'm at work
 
Re: Fortune changes, since there seems to be a lot of discourse/confusion regarding "why change these tools specifically" given some of the changes are targeting stuff that isn't complained about as much as other tools.

At a very (very) basic level, I think there are 2 general ways you can go about bringing down a character's strength; you either weaken their strong tools to bring them more in line with the rest of the cast or you increase their weaknesses as compensation for their strengths. While the Fortune changes so far do have a couple changes which fit the former (jLK, air hurtbox), I think overall they fit within the latter. Imo this is a more fun and interesting way of toning Fortune down than just directly nerfing all the strong tools that people complain about since it means that she can still do all or at least most of the cool stuff that's fun about her, it's just she will explode more if she gets hit/pressure.

So I think we can interpret the Fortune changes so far as toning down her strengths that are seen as overly egregious (like her small air hurtbox making her hard to hit and her jLK pressure) while giving her bigger weaknesses on defence to compensate for her still really strong offence and neutral. So while I doubt anyone was complaining about headless H Fiber's throw invuln before (or suggesting that head-on Fiber becomes only strike invuln), I think we can view these changes through the lens of giving Fortune appropriate weaknesses to compensate for her strengths.

Obviously I'm not Liam/HV and this is just how I am viewing the Fortune changes but I think they make sense when viewed in this way and I prefer this approach to just giving really big nerfs to all of Fortune's strong, fun tools.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate your explanation but I don't think I can really agree on this one I can understand the intent of toning down a character and I get that it opens up throwing more as an option against the character therefore giving it a downside (though personally I thought being minus on block was downside enough) but I think because specific counterplay already exists i.e air resets which is more or less the entirety of the game which to me makes it much too negligible to even matter so I'm not really for it. At least for me, if solution already exists and is a feasible option i.e. block the fiber or air reset fortune then it's very hard for me to be okay with something. I feel like they're tools that can be counterpicked or have counterplay to them but are overall unused (most people don't even run a DP anymore though maybe that's changing with Fortune's new prevalence) and at least in CEO 2021 using a DP assist against two fortune's in top 8 put in a lot of work and this is retail where she keeps her strengths.

Again, I appreciate the explanation and I understand where you're coming from but I think I just have to agree to disagree. If it stays I think Fortune will probably be fine but I don't agree with the philosophy behind it.
 
Last edited:
This. For the love of god, this


I would post the comparison images with other characters' anchor point, but I'm not near my computer atm since I'm at work
This was discussed in the Skullgirls Discord beta discussion back in March, and unfortunately there was no plan to change Bella. It's just a character quirk. (pain)
 
"First they came for the Peacock mains, and I did not speak out-
Because I was not a Peacock main"


"Then they came for the Annie mains, and I did not speak out-

Because I was not a Annie main"


"Then they came for the Miss Fortune mains, and I did not speak out-

Because I was not a Miss Fortune main"



"Then they came for my main - And there was no one left to speak for me"
soon as character defining traits & tools are stripped, game balance-wise is downhill from there. eventually no one will be able to have anything remotely strong in the sense of making people truly think about how to not autopilot. Which is the entire point — something you play around. reasonable counter play already exists for these scenarios.

in the history of fg’s as a general rule of thumb giving everyone dope things has been more positive than anything else. Dbfz big boi patch solved a lot & brought people back (Zamasu, nappa, goku black, etc), Sg ’cristmas’ patch from forever ago made people ease up on band & peacock when everyone got new stuff, people loving the gratuitous craziness in dnf duel wanting more, MK11 finally allowing custom variations online, enduring love for diversity on everyone in blazblue/gg characters, recent biggish strive patch…list goes on & on & on. anyone with longstanding grievances almost always forget about them in lieu of having new toys to play with & new solutions to older puzzles. I don’t get why this is such a sticking point…I really don’t. We’ve been through this before multiple times, multiple games. its not rocket science.

nerfing characters past a certain point rarely results in a net positive. Nerf one…people will just focus on another characters annoyance to funnel frustration. or straight up stop playing certain characters if grieved enough. That stilts matchups even more. like before, I get cat heads & annies lvl2, stuff like that — but the trend should be pretty clear by now. when everyone gets cool things there’s very little room for unhappy players as whole.

My own words, but personally I don’t wanna win more because I took away reasonable tools from someone else. I know some probably don’t see it like that but I do. much rather move on to talks about potential new system or even character mechanics…things to further the game & level of play, not hinder it. I just wanna get back to being excited about the game in a new way. it’s what fgs have always been about. no need to overthink it.

edit: melty just dropped a new update…and followed the same philosophy as well. Inserted some comments from update reactions/comments. this is the type of excitement that happens from unexpected hype
 

Attachments

  • 80A9093E-73B2-42E8-8E0E-5CE194193FDD.png
    80A9093E-73B2-42E8-8E0E-5CE194193FDD.png
    307.5 KB · Views: 331
  • 5E1D7DE0-4916-4877-9671-D31980B2B02C.jpeg
    5E1D7DE0-4916-4877-9671-D31980B2B02C.jpeg
    216.8 KB · Views: 332
  • 982BB238-AF0E-4F4D-9A07-879A96BE71F7.jpeg
    982BB238-AF0E-4F4D-9A07-879A96BE71F7.jpeg
    75.7 KB · Views: 332
  • 4797B10F-C77F-47DF-A7AA-7E057DA661CA.jpeg
    4797B10F-C77F-47DF-A7AA-7E057DA661CA.jpeg
    57.5 KB · Views: 328
  • 1E024BC8-3B00-4989-8A05-91B33A6F44A1.jpeg
    1E024BC8-3B00-4989-8A05-91B33A6F44A1.jpeg
    96.4 KB · Views: 335
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ikkisoad
what are the chances that this late in the games life we can finally get the awkward assist macro combinations to be adjusted

stuff has an image from a long ass time ago i think

It would just be really really nice to do HK specials with a1 input and LP specials with A2 input

in most instances you can just plink but some times you can't ( a lot of pw hbuer+assist stuff has strict timings) and stuff like htrain SKD, max range ebrake (HK~hp) + assist 1 is just so awkward
 
what are the chances that this late in the games life we can finally get the awkward assist macro combinations to be adjusted

stuff has an image from a long ass time ago i think

It would just be really really nice to do HK specials with a1 input and LP specials with A2 input

in most instances you can just plink but some times you can't ( a lot of pw hbuer+assist stuff has strict timings) and stuff like htrain SKD, max range ebrake (HK~hp) + assist 1 is just so awkward

Yes please, this has been something I've wanted to try since day 1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bbp
This was discussed in the Skullgirls Discord beta discussion back in March, and unfortunately there was no plan to change Bella. It's just a character quirk. (pain)
For future reference to others who'd want something visual to refer to, these are where some of the anchor points are for some of the characters when they are in a "falling headfirst" hitstun state.

Some combos don't work on Bella and Double because they hit the ground earlier than other characters and can therefore ground tech sooner (it's fine and makes sense for Double since she's tall and heavy, but Bella?)
 

Attachments

  • SkullGirls_6C3UWOqTxn.jpg
    SkullGirls_6C3UWOqTxn.jpg
    149.7 KB · Views: 382
  • SkullGirls_hftzSxNSNe.jpg
    SkullGirls_hftzSxNSNe.jpg
    153.5 KB · Views: 368
  • SkullGirls_FvEY4Nkbx4.jpg
    SkullGirls_FvEY4Nkbx4.jpg
    140.9 KB · Views: 364
  • SkullGirls_X9K6KsGkgw.jpg
    SkullGirls_X9K6KsGkgw.jpg
    201.5 KB · Views: 372
  • SkullGirls_92ZvawQwL3.jpg
    SkullGirls_92ZvawQwL3.jpg
    138.3 KB · Views: 374
Headless Fortune's weakness is lack of a reliable reversal (without proper head position, you basically don't have a reversal while headless). She has two amazing reversals in terms of sneeze and nom, and doesn't need another reversal on top of it.
even with proper head positioning, you can't use nom or sneeze on your own wake up, as it shifts its cooldown only till you get back up. so she only gets CSF and feral (if the opponent doesn't counter super, or even sometimes a normal will just beat it). There's also level 3 if you really wanna spend a lot of bar. so her main reversals are very easily baited and come down to which metered super she will use. There is not much else that I'm aware of she can use to keep her opponent on their toes. for real if I'm missing something here, tell me.
 
For a game that hasn't had any changes for 5 years I'm surprised at the amount of the "yeah she's fine" and "yeah that's fair" from the players. This is Skullgirls my dudes. This game is not fair, these characters are not fine, and you shouldn't want them to be. It's pretty disappointing to hear so many players say "I can't wait for Annie to get nerfed" in person. It feels like the community old and new have been spoiled by the fact things can change. I'm no exception to this, but come on.

Peacock: She's still good, but I'm not fond of the extra changes she got for the current beta. I think the changes she got last patch were enough and only really changed how much Peacock could get away with doing the punch move. The reward on some stuff was a little less, but overall Peacock players could run the game plan they've developed these past 5 years. Now we're going back 7 years, that's just weird to me.

Robo: H Beam just looks weird now. I always felt the beam assist should be OP and it happening off screen complimented that idea. If it was on another character then sure but... its Robo man!

Annie: Her changes are very boring. Another example of a character still being good after being toned down, but she doesn't even feel like herself anymore.

H Knuckle Assist: This assist nerf feels horrible. This is like almost as bad as when excellabella got toned down (rightfully so, but they went too ham). If an assist is too strong then its okay to tone it down, but if you do it this much then you make players not want to pick it. As a result players will feel like they need to change teams or a strategy they worked hard on and that is not fun. I would recommend adding more time before Annie leaves the screen. This would make it more like Brass where on offense its OD, but for neutral situations you have to go out of your way to protect it or its getting locked out. Let it do its thing!

j.MP: Been said a hundred times, it just feels awful. It sucks seeing the resets Sonic developed go. Sucks watching the combo Shade developed and did for months disappear. Every Annie on my stream is in shambles every game. The combos that still do work feel wonky too. If the goal was to lower her damage and combo potential then this change did its job, but I don't think we needed this!

Point pillar: This super costs 2 bars, but its a meme right now. Hoping to see it changed back!

6HP & 5MP: The changes made it so things like spaced 6HP dash 5HP -> dive kick doesn't work. This is like the Lugar change where it still works point blank, but that's it. This was sick and I'm sad to see it go. I love crazy stuff like this man.

Knuckle & Dive Kick: These moves losing so much of their impact really takes away from her character. These moves had so much power to them. I'd like to see it back.

Before she felt so smooth to play and everything clicked together so well. Strong hits made her feel powerful and the hits had impact. The other changes don't bother me as much, but these are ugly!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Umbrella:

This character is incredible.

M Bubble: The recent changes to this move really make her feel complete. Neutral is interesting and creative thanks to it popping towards the opponent. A bubble is out and someone jumps over you? Slide into the bubble and get a cross under hit from the pop. Killed a character in the corner? Set up M bubble and get a free left/right incoming mix up. Playing footsies? Make your big button even BIGGER. I love this.

H Bubble: I think most players want this move to interact with projectiles, but I'm unsure if I would want that. I think its fine as is for now, but if it were to change then maybe it going away if Umbrella gets hit makes more sense. This is the other move that made her toolkit feel complete and really opened up her ability to set up or get into ravenous.

Ravenous: This mode is OD. Getting an instant overhead completely changes this character. You can also get into Ravenous after landing a single hit pretty easily. This makes her very scary since her low hunger damage is kind of absurd right now.

H Bubble -> M Bubble sets up Rising j.MP J.MK -> 5MK 6HP -> command grab which = goodbye

Slide while in this mode is also crazy oppressive! You're +4 even if you get push blocked and you're still in 5MP range. Bro, I love the vision.

Salt Grinder: If you get hit into this and then reset back into this you can die for 1 bar. Makes me feel like every character I play is Beowulf. I personally love this, but if it does get changed please don't let it be scaling like excellabella. I don't know if my heart can take it.


Reflector: Right now I think the only OP thing about her is this level 1 super. This super is nuts and doesn't go away when she gets hit either which is incredible.
Godlike vs Projectiles too... I just learned Robo beam can't go through it. If it goes away when she gets hit it'd still be OP and I like that.

Under The Weather: I lied this super might also be OP. This super reminds me of monsters ability to control space, while also giving way more characters safe tags and dhcs. Being able to use it to drop your opponents undizzy bar safely is an option that isn't too common in this game. You can also use it to lower your hunger too, so you can choose to spend less undizzy to get into ravenous and then wait for the super to drop the opponents undizzy and then 50/50 them.

If she ends up getting changes from here, I hope she still hits hard and she keeps the creative freedom from her current tool kit. If she were to end up released as she is right now she would make a big splash in the meta the same way Annie did and that'd be really nice to see again.


My writing is horrible, but if you read this thanks. Take it easy fellas.
 
I wanted to add that I thought meter steal was a very cool concept that opened up a new strat in denying somebody the ability to safe DHC which is a very strong option, I thought this was very cool (I kind of felt like it solved one of my issues with the game without outright removing anything). Obv because pillar of creation had other strengths (strengths I'd happily give up because I thought it was much more interesting than more of the usual [big damage and ez conversion]), it had to be removed but I'm really hoping that some day for some character this very awesome concept can be seen again.

I really loved subtracting 1-.5 bars from my opponent's 2 so that they can't rely on their bnb of: "super xx super > my turn now". IDK I just thought it was an interesting counter tool. Removing their super option if it was 1 bar was also very satisfying, I loved it so so much, it was a different way to force the opponent to block.

I thought it was really really cool....
ᵍᵒᵈ ʷʰᵃᵗ ᵃ ᶜᵒᵒˡ ᶜᵒⁿᶜᵉᵖᵗ
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: missingno
Yeah I also think meter steal is a cool concept, but it just seemed out of place on a character like Annie and on the particular move which doesn't seem to have anything to do with draining the opponent. Would be neat to see it on another character where it fits the character/move theme more.
 
Gonna have to hard disagree about reverting Annie to her fullpower

With other fighting games, they tend to have larger character rosters, so the disparity between their strengths is more prevalent. With Skullgirls, balancing the cast is a bit more manageable (gonna be harder going forward with more characters).

Annie was so powerful that the majority of the playerbase was picking her up, including me, either on main teams or pocketing her. Why? Because it made no sense not to considering her vast array of strengths to the point of being at a disadvantage for not playing her.

It's to the point where many top players will give advice to newer players picking up the game/learning new teams saying "Just pick Annie"

It reminds me so much of week 1 Fukua where everyone was using her and saying "Just pick Fukua," and I don't want to go back to that. The thought is making me recoil.

At the very least, Annie lv2 should not be reverted. Pre-nerf, it was better than many lv3 supers in the game, and that doesn't make any sense to me.
 
I dont think anyone wants her to be fully reverted back as some of her strengths like pillar were overbearing. But there are certain things that I personally feel shouldnt have been toned down the way that they were when they werent the issues with Annie (dash speed, J.MP, and assists). I’m not alone on this opinion either.

I’m all for new meta characters, and personally the Robo Annie Meta that I helped shape was one of my favorite teams to play in the history of this game. The fact that the nerfs received to Annie took away all the creativity and strategy I worked with on that team this past year kinda sucks a lot, and those assist changes aren’t the only teams poorly effected by her now.

I don’t want to be purposely dissuaded to play an assist. She has now two cases where it just seems like the devs straight up went “ya don’t use this” which is now H knuckle and Install DHC and I feel that goes against a lot of the creativity and what “could be” that SG has always cherished as it’s strong points for years.

I don’t want my hard work to feel like it was all for nothing ultimately which is why I believe there are more elegant ways of toning down other issues of Annie, damage and Pillar primarily being her issues.
 
(Re-edited)
i just hope we don’t let Annie install waste away. I know last round was messy but seems like a core mechanic dictating a major way she plays was ignored.

Also PME, I’d assert that people picked her up in the beginning not solely because of damage (tho dhc was part of it), but because she was actually interesting in terms of newfound flexibility for a core mechanic unlike anything we’ve seen before in sg. Was kinda half-baked, but It fr felt like a new frontier w/Sol jr. at first I didn’t care, but totally won me over with flavour & attitude. to be clear tho, definitely dont want that reversion back.

Tone base damage down if needed, but let install be as cool as It is from sgmobile. not saying keep same method of resource-gain since 40secs to fill is too long, but I invite anyone to take a look who hasn’t seen it already/in a while. RC mechanic ties it together well & i like the freedom yet limited amount of strings you can do.

starts @2:30 for quick 3min breakdown


been thinking about these details since release, just letting readers know it wasn’t created on the spot. couple people‘ve seen the google doc already, anyways hopefully sparks some ideas

Stars & Specials:
stars only activate on whiff w/faster recovery for followups, but normals stop shooting stars after direct contact from Annie on hit or block. this way, they don’t mess up normal bnbs & catheads vibes are gone while giving her powered up specials in its place for bombos/creativity. it’s fairly evident the extended catheads lockdown effect (regardless of thoughts on PBGCs) is the biggest roadblock in the way of interactivity. Besides H-versions, stars would work the same as respective strength crescent cuts for distance/speed/damage & a bit more stun while annie recovers faster to approach. this way people actually have a reason to use for neutral as designed, over just j.hp as a more complete tool. I make this a point because rn there’s no reason using them as distance/stun/recovery is awkward & you’re left where you started (like eliza throne) unless using H stars. small note, you can still purposefully whiff & continue combos in all sorts of situations with this. Resets as well. Basically the theme is, you have a lot more help/pressure for getting in as a complete package, but over-oppression stops when you do. sauce-wise you’re rewarded with powered up specials in place of extra stars being gone since it is an install.

Resource or Meter:
i see making SP its own resource via holy order sol; naturally, no meter gain during use. if we stick to bar, making it like sekh where 1 meter drains normally with *no* exit penalty, then each concurrent meter drains noticeably faster than the last. most importantly, exiting pauses meter gain for a small bit, allowing for quick in & outs without effecting SP or cost. risk-wise put her permanent counter hit state &/or knockdowns force exit with loss of a bit of meter/resource (like ABA from GG+R). theres Many creative ways to give it a nice risk/reward so it’s not an eyerolling affair for the opponent, but moreso an opportunity for a blowup on their side. allow the punish, welcome it. but let install itself be a real power fantasy. something legitimately fun While being engaging for the defender in a good way.

Pillar of Creation:
significantly more scaled lvl3 or non-comboable ok-damage hard knockdown while completely refilling resource on hit. if meter‘s still a thing, next install’s free for 3bars & little payoff, but good oki w/hkd for install pressure & opponent still has a chance to get out. i like that as a compromise while tying into her identity (like umbrellas lvl 3 & hunger).

Final Note:
I hope no one single detail was anything to distract from the overall cohesion in mind. regardless of what we all think individually, Im optimistic we can all have something to be hype about for the future of Sg. And thanks for reading if you made it this far — bless up
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DoubleOrNothing
Gonna have to hard disagree about reverting Annie to her fullpower
People aren't asking for that
With other fighting games, they tend to have larger character rosters, so the disparity between their strengths is more prevalent. With Skullgirls, balancing the cast is a bit more manageable (gonna be harder going forward with more characters).
Some characters core kits are concepts are volatile to a certain degree. Beo will never not rely on assists that give him hype, same with valentine, it makes creative explorations with certain characters a dry well

As long as everyone has the core abilities to open people up Low-Overheads-Grabs-Mix-ups whatever, everyone will be strong within the right hands, that's what sets skullgirls apart. Everyone has the necessities to do damage woven into the themes and flavor of their character. I think what should be avoided is absolutely BRAINDEAD gameplay decisions. Annie pillar DHC is the most mind-numbingly braindead sequence I have ever had the pleasure of experiencing more times than I have fought eliza players in bracket
Annie was so powerful that the majority of the playerbase was picking her up, including me, either on main teams or pocketing her. Why? Because it made no sense not to considering her vast array of strengths to the point of being at a disadvantage for not playing her.
You are not at a disadvantage when NOT playing annie, even in her current retail iteration. She has a very clumsy sequence to her normals, her gameplay is ridiculously straight forward, and she was basically doing what Double does, except in the air to such an technical ease, you would be hard pressed NOT to recommend her to any stiff-fingered newcomer who joined Skullgirls in this revitalized era. This feels to me like how solo big bands can kill characters because one got mashed on by SSJ twice and thinks "Wow that's so braindead oh well he's big band"

Annie is more braindead than she is powerful, she IS powerful, but not to the degree of breaking the game, I'd argue she needs less damage rather than anything else
It's to the point where many top players will give advice to newer players picking up the game/learning new teams saying "Just pick Annie"
I attribute this to her incredible easiness to play, and pillar DHC and just overall hype around the character
At the very least, Annie lv2 should not be reverted. Pre-nerf, it was better than many lv3 supers in the game, and that doesn't make any sense to me.
YES
(Re-edited)
i just hope we don’t let Annie install waste away.
Annie Install needs a rework. She has too many well damage supers that are enough to kill characters at a meta-friendly optimal level. This dissuades use of the Install for damage, even when one carries knowledge of how to use it

The mixup options from install just seem like Redux versions of mixups she already HAS, and precedent with other characters such as Eliza show that Meter-Drain is not an enticing at all mechanic

The two supers you get FROM install are outclassed by her other regular supers, which you LOSE access to in install

And stars promote the big problem with annie which is how braindeadingly rewarding it is to airdash over someone fifty times throwing heavy hitstun stars while an assist can cover you AND You have a level 1, easy to mash, Burst super

TL:DR - Update targeted too much stuff with Annie, Poor direction for how she should be changed in my opinion

Annie install is wack

The game should be everyone doing everything with the assist of a gimmick, not a character being nothing BUT the gimmick (Beowulf)
 
While I wouldn’t say that people are asking for Annie to go back to full power, people are definitely acting like she’s in a pretty bad spot rn and imo downplaying just how strong she was. Ceo had 6/8 teams have Annie in top 8 and I don’t even think launch Fukua was that bad and she was arguably easier than Annie. While her being braindead easy definitely contributed to her pick rate, I think her overall strength was the strongest factor.

I also think she’s still in the great spot and one of the stronger characters rn. I think all of her changes were pretty fair and the only ones I would really consider reverting are the j.mp and dash changes and not because they were too harsh, but to let Annie players have more fun cause those aren’t what broke her.

While we’re on the topic of fun I’m curious as to what the fun parts of Annie were to people. Not to be presumptuous but to me it feels like a lot of people’s “fun” with Annie came from her being so powerful and less about Annie herself being fun to play. I feel like if we can focus on what was fun about Annie (minus her just being strong), we can focus on lowering her power level to a more reasonable level while still keeping the aspects of her people found fun intact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PME and Sajurf
While I wouldn’t say that people are asking for Annie to go back to full power, people are definitely acting like she’s in a pretty bad spot rn and imo downplaying just how strong she was. Ceo had 6/8 teams have Annie in top 8 and I don’t even think launch Fukua was that bad and she was arguably easier than Annie. While her being braindead easy definitely contributed to her pick rate, I think her overall strength was the strongest factor.

I also think she’s still in the great spot and one of the stronger characters rn. I think all of her changes were pretty fair and the only ones I would really consider reverting are the j.mp and dash changes and not because they were too harsh, but to let Annie players have more fun cause those aren’t what broke her.

While we’re on the topic of fun I’m curious as to what the fun parts of Annie were to people. Not to be presumptuous but to me it feels like a lot of people’s “fun” with Annie came from her being so powerful and less about Annie herself being fun to play. I feel like if we can focus on what was fun about Annie (minus her just being strong), we can focus on lowering her power level to a more reasonable level while still keeping the aspects of her people found fun intact.
I don’t think anyone is saying she’s in a bad spot in terms of working as a character — all characters ‘work’ in game but echoing a tiny bit of what killsage said, but moreso triv…the design right now as a whole isn’t fine. You’re seeing it in terms of strength, others see (I’m assuming) in terms of style, identity & motivation. There’s zero motivation to take anything but the path of least resistance with her. Install & pillar being main culprits. hard to put in words, but If anything, a creative nerf is being asked for. a rework. so she’s not so…mind-numbingly easy to play, yet interesting.

Just as well correlation isn’t causation — did you notice anything in CEO/fall blockbuster on where people included Annie? Never point, only mid or anchor. many other toons have primary favoured positions sure, but it points to her (relative) weakness in neutral overshadowed by Pillar. you have to figure in how she’s getting in, not that she’s just strong or being put on teams. retroactive edit to lex: you're right, there are always exceptions to the rule, but i mean on average people seem to min/max the same way & seems indicative of pillar being the issue.

going on a tangent conversely, eliza, squigly & painwheel hardly showed up. Point, mid or anchor. No, of course they’re not BAD. But realistically in terms of viable options & flexibility…they don’t have as much &/or gotta work harder. in other words they’re weaker by the same logic put forth. People in my observation are fine with working harder or having not as many good matchups long as they have options (enter robo). I love the challenge personally but I was the only point squigly on stream for semis tmk. you saw primarily bella, peacock, band, para, double, filia, fortune & even more beo. They get better return on investment quite plainly. The overarching sentiment seems clear to me: people like flexibility, not just strength. annie is strong…after you dhc, but not very flexible. otherwise shed play point more.

sticking to what I mentioned before, install was the fun imo. There was a lot of install combo vids from sgmobile & pc version from release months ago. Core mechanics is (usually) what draw peopleon average in my view…why else is gg+r respected? Other games got fun mechanics too but characters & flavour is the soul. With that said let’s make her great again. As well as putting other characters in step with more flexible mechanics.
 
Last edited:
did you notice anything in CEO/fall blockbuster on where people included Annie? Never point, only mid or anchor. many other toons have primary favoured positions sure, but it points to her weakness in neutral overshadowed by Pillar.
Sonic has been putting in work all year with point Annie (and Milk Pouch, iControl & Dhoppler have also all made top 8s at big online tournaments this year with point Annie teams). So I think there's decent tournament representation for point Annie. And I'd say that the reason you generally see Annie mid is not because of weaknesses on point but because of how strong and easy Pillar of Creation DHC is, which heavily incentivises putting her mid.

Generally speaking, every character is good on point because that's the spot where you can compensate for any weaknesses with assists/DHCs. If a character is usually seen mid or anchor it's because they have notable strengths that incentivise putting them there, not because they have weaknesses on point.

going on a tangent conversely, eliza, squigly & painwheel hardly showed up. Point, mid or anchor. No, of course they’re not BAD.
Painwheel and Squigly actually have had quite a bit of tournament success this year. In terms of top 8 appearances within the Evos and SGCS Majors/Minors they're both roughly middle of the pack in terms of appearances (PW's actually in the top half). Eliza is the only one of those 3 who actually has notably low tournament representation (though saying that, both she and Squig were in the CEO top 8...).

Obviously there are some flaws with judging character strength just off of tournament appearances (eg favours flexible characters, individual really strong players who play in lots of tournaments can skew the results, etc) but it seems like you've just chosen 3 characters that you think are weak and assumed that they haven't had success here, when that's really not the case.

I don't particularly have a strong opinion in the "revert/tone down Annie nerfs" argument, I just wanted to correct these points.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ikkisoad
Sonic has been putting in work all year with point Annie (and Milk Pouch, iControl & Dhoppler have also all made top 8s at big online tournaments this year with point Annie teams). So I think there's decent tournament representation for point Annie. And I'd say that the reason you generally see Annie mid is not because of weaknesses on point but because of how strong and easy Pillar of Creation DHC is, which heavily incentivises putting her mid.

Generally speaking, every character is good on point because that's the spot where you can compensate for any weaknesses with assists/DHCs. If a character is usually seen mid or anchor it's because they have notable strengths that incentivise putting them there, not because they have weaknesses on point.


Painwheel and Squigly actually have had quite a bit of tournament success this year. In terms of top 8 appearances within the Evos and SGCS Majors/Minors they're both roughly middle of the pack in terms of appearances (PW's actually in the top half). Eliza is the only one of those 3 who actually has notably low tournament representation (though saying that, both she and Squig were in the CEO top 8...).

Obviously there are some flaws with judging character strength just off of tournament appearances (eg favours flexible characters, individual really strong players who play in lots of tournaments can skew the results, etc) but it seems like you've just chosen 3 characters that you think are weak and assumed that they haven't had success here, when that's really not the case.

I don't particularly have a strong opinion in the "revert/tone down Annie nerfs" argument, I just wanted to correct these points.
I was mainly responding to most recently. Last year yeah there was a bit of variety, but I’m talking recently. as in current character habits/patterns on teams coming out of pools. Especially drops or changed team order after changes/etc.

i'd say we mostly agree though. I was going by what PME said & using that lens to talk about characters In a pointed way to illustrate it. of course you can’t judge tourneys as end all be all but it still begs the question why some are & arent seen as much regardless Of variance or player strength & I think it’s not fair to write that off just because we’ve seen them before. Can’t have it just one way. I mean…I use squigly & Eliza, if anyone champions use it’s me, but saying those characters are being cherry picked is overlooking what I as well as many others been saying over a sustained period of time or are squelched after trying to.

they’re not bad, there's no bad characters. But in the same way ‘fine’ shouldn’t be the standard for certain things, saying ‘hey look they popped up here’ isn’t either. overall on average they're in the lower rungs of appearance but youre right, they're not completely MIA. importantly though doesn’t negate them being characters people want more for. just wanna make it unequivocally clear: not trying to decide who’s better or worse since i never saw it like that. but instead that more change is wanted. ill try to keep points more succinct next time

Retroactive Edit to Sinclair to not derail
Every character has made top8 & already beo & robo have gotten cool overhauls. Dont see the point there. Supers are another discussion but specials being more positive/rewarding is fair considering parasols egrets, fukuas clones, robos drones, fortunes head & peacocks brigade assist-type specials allow for that character to get in. Being positive/getting better rewards isnt an unfair ask. Additionally s.hp/s.hk are slower than most specials so yeah i agree shaving some frames would be nice as well.
 
Last edited:
While I wouldn’t say that people are asking for Annie to go back to full power, people are definitely acting like she’s in a pretty bad spot rn and imo downplaying just how strong she was. Ceo had 6/8 teams have Annie in top 8 and I don’t even think launch Fukua was that bad and she was arguably easier than Annie. While her being braindead easy definitely contributed to her pick rate, I think her overall strength was the strongest factor.

I also think she’s still in the great spot and one of the stronger characters rn. I think all of her changes were pretty fair and the only ones I would really consider reverting are the j.mp and dash changes and not because they were too harsh, but to let Annie players have more fun cause those aren’t what broke her.

While we’re on the topic of fun I’m curious as to what the fun parts of Annie were to people. Not to be presumptuous but to me it feels like a lot of people’s “fun” with Annie came from her being so powerful and less about Annie herself being fun to play. I feel like if we can focus on what was fun about Annie (minus her just being strong), we can focus on lowering her power level to a more reasonable level while still keeping the aspects of her people found fun intact.
For me, one of the most fun things about Annie was slowing the pace of the game down. It made some of the volatile offense that people ran in this game have to think twice about doing it. The mindgame (minus if youre filia) was pretty straightforward with running behind Crescent or to disengage. Due to dash speeds changing, now she feels like this awkward zoner.

The other fun part of playing Annie is just playing neutral with strong grounded footsies. On point, I feel she has to think a little harder than most characters to hit the opponent, and the most common way is counterplaying them since she has the tools to answer almost everything in neutral. If you had good fundamentals and good SG game sense, playing her spacing game and pressure game I think is some of the most fun I’ve had in SG. It feels like I’m making the other player have to interact with my personal strengths (footsies and space control) a lot, and the closest character in this game that does it almost as good as Annie is Parasoul!

ESPECIALLY if the opponent over extends in a situation where I jump back and whiff punish with J.HP. There is nothing more satisfying to me than them falling into J.HP traps where it’ll hit them or be at the perfect spacing where it is a 50/50 when I punish the opponent’s overextension.
 
Thank you for explaining, that opened my eyes more on what Annie (or at least you) enjoy with her. I would assume then that in your eyes the ideal nerfs for her would be like slightly lower damage and a pillar nerf of some sorts correct? If so I 100% agree with you. I always felt the two biggest problems with her was how hard she exploded you and how easy pillar enabled it. Honestly I would have been satisfied if those were the only areas of hers that got targeted by the changes.

This may come as a shock but I always thought annie was just some small tuning away from being perfect and never wanted her gutted nearly as bad as other people seemed to. I agreed with your initial impressions on the changes (minus making point pillar better) it just felt like people were downplaying how strong she was andbacting like you had no reason to play her now when the changes weren’t that bad. Which I guess goes back to the stuff I said earlier about double about how people don’t really clarify if they mean something is less fun vs it being bad. Thanks again for clarifying your stance so I can see you and the other Annie’s perspectives better
 
For me, one of the most fun things about Annie was slowing the pace of the game down
Pretty sure this is because having 2 bars halted 80% of the cast from moving at all

Let me clarify: It wasn't using pillar that halted neutral, it was the threat of it. Simply having 2 bars let her control the pace of the match, not spending it, just having 2 bars did that.

But after seeing more of Annie recently, it seems fair to change back jMP, but damage nerfs and current pillar nerf should stay.

On the topic of install, I actually think the stars should have more blockstun. Currently, they have so little blockstun that it's hard to pushblock Annie away, which causes accidental backdashes into getting tagged by another star. But that's more of a personal opinion in terms of tweaking install than anything, since the ADC jHP in install not producing stars already helps with this a bit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: softie and Ikkisoad
I personally liked how destructive Annie was because it made it so that people died when I hit them, I miss Double level 5 for the same reason the game is more fun when I have to deal with you the least. Currently a lot of the game is heavily lopsided to band for the same reason, I liked that Annie was/is an alternative to BIg Band while being fun and having a different form of versatility. I don't think she was going to dominate the meta as a glue character as assists like brass were suitable to counter calling an assist like this and I also think it opens up more reason to snap in Annie to remove that utility she has from just being on the second slot. I think the conversion distances were pretty ridiculous so I think that itself was a good call.

I also miss the size of her jHP stars (and the fact that you could shoot them more than once), though obv they couldn't be kept because usually a good defensive tool tends to be an enormously strong offensive tool. I really did think Annie slowed down the game H Crescent is (thankfully) a great neutral tool I don't think her dash speed being slower makes her less of a defensive character, if anything Annie will probably be fine if that part stays I think Annie's kit lended her to being able to back off and press a button as a threat and that was a lot of fun, reminds me of Painwheel except really good and less effort (I still think Painwheel is secret S-Tier provided you're a robot). I don't really play characters for the damage (despite me liking you dying when I hit you) I like them for the neutral game and Annie's was fun. She could really set the pace with larger normals and a projectile, kind of like a grounded version of Valentine.

H Knuckle was doomed to be nerfed as it does damage and corner carry and it's two hits so it's like H bomber except a lot better. I think just lowering the damage could be fine the carry I feel is the part I thought was cooler, you could birthday carry pretty far with quite a few characters which made it so you can punish bad calls a lot easier, again making it so that you have to think about pressing that assist.

Basically Annie made it so that I could punish any stupid idea, it made it so that you (my opponent) actually had to think about your approach. THIS WAS AWESOME

It was also a good match up for PW imo which made her more relevant with Annie becoming more relevant. (Even though nobody still players her lol)

I'm still pretty hopeful that Annie can still do this though personally I was only in it for the meter steal and install and those seem to be going away bit by bit. I stopped playing her after meter steal left...

It was just nice to have options that do similar things or better on different characters I think SG is desperate for a change like this to up overall team viability rather than having to rely on like 4 characters.

I just don't want it to go back to double band bella (even though they never left) Zzzzzzzz

Unrelated: I was wondering if meter gain could be scaled by ratio as well as it's currently the only thing that *isn't* (Val's vials, health, damage are all scaled by ratio)

EDIT: Honestly Annie is still pretty strong despite the nerfs, I've gotten to play penpen two times now and she seems fine though I still personally like stuff like H knuckle assist and also it's weird seeing it go away but she still provides beat extend 2 but with also tons of carry. Personally I'd like it if more characters had the utility and strength of Annie
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure this is because having 2 bars halted 80% of the cast from moving at all

Let me clarify: It wasn't using pillar that halted neutral, it was the threat of it. Simply having 2 bars let her control the pace of the match, not spending it, just having 2 bars did that.

But after seeing more of Annie recently, it seems fair to change back jMP, but damage nerfs and current pillar nerf should stay.

On the topic of install, I actually think the stars should have more blockstun. Currently, they have so little blockstun that it's hard to pushblock Annie away, which causes accidental backdashes into getting tagged by another star. But that's more of a personal opinion in terms of tweaking install than anything, since the ADC jHP in install not producing stars already helps with this a bit.
My post was in relation to her whole toolkit and not pillar of creation to clarify. H crescent is the name of the game with her on point. Yes I enjoyed using a fireball and playing a slow methodical neutral game with her and now it feels I only zone with it.

You don’t play to use Pillar on point, you play to kill them after a reset by meter dumping. Pillar on point was a rarity, but it was clutch when it came into play. Again I agree with the damage nerfs and Pillar as I felt those were the only areas that should have been nerfed. Everything else was just a bit excessive.
 
Last edited:
I just remembered something, since hurtbox changes seem to be happening, is bella going to get changed so that her hurtboxes will be more in line with other characters or will she always be bonkers in that regard?
 
While we’re on the topic of fun I’m curious as to what the fun parts of Annie were to people. Not to be presumptuous but to me it feels like a lot of people’s “fun” with Annie came from her being so powerful and less about Annie herself being fun to play. I feel like if we can focus on what was fun about Annie (minus her just being strong), we can focus on lowering her power level to a more reasonable level while still keeping the aspects of her people found fun intact.

Install, install combos, stars, routing, reverse routing, s.HK star sending people flying. I thought it was the coolest thing, and also the idea of having another character besides PW having an install? When I first saw it I thought of it as going Super Saiyan.
 
I just wanna throw this out there but why did robo level 3 install get the nerfs that it got, it feels so mechanically stiff now to what it once was
 
  • Like
Reactions: DomiWizza
Can Painwheel get her old beta armor back?
 
I think it’s not fair to write that off just because we’ve seen them before
It is absolutely fine to write off characters as good enough because we've seen them before in top 8.

The issue with Eliza isn't that she's bad. She just has to put in way more effort in doing certain things when other characters have it easier. And in a tournament environment you generally just want characters that can make more mistakes but are ALLOWED to make these mistakes. Eliza isn't that type of character. And that is absolutely fine. She is fine. She has her strengths and weaknesses. She's just not viable in high level tournaments because 1 mistake can cause the match to snowball in the favour of your opponent.
And you know what? That's fine. Putting in the extra extra effort is okay. And like lex said, we have seen Eliza pop up in CEO top 8. Which means it's not impossible for her to get that high. A lot of people just don't want to play her. Maybe she's boring, maybe she's frustrating. But she can get there.
I generally do not think characters should be homogenized (is that the word lol) so they are all "viable" in a certain environment. And the extra effort (and stress) is imo fun for me when I play tourneys :o)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TyroneOCanada
I want to play her and would like for her to have a much more consistent overhead, it's currently really hard. It can even whiff point blank and that's with jHP kara adc jLK, that sucks. Her double overhead is also a lot more challenging than it is for the rest of the cast and can also whiff (jLK jMP [jMK also has some moments where it whiffs after jLK]) It's okay for a character to lose when it messes up but it's also just so EASY to mess up that it's really hard to justify playing her.

Eliza also hard struggles against zoners while having the least utility in the game, and imo she actually has the beowulf problem where she just needs to have a neutral assist, which isn't necessarily a bad thing but I'm just saying when there's more of the cast that's more inherently useful than eliza, that's a problem that should be fixed.

She can still be a hard character, I love the way her toolkit works, I'd just like it to be more useful more often.

Her pokes? Amazing. I'd like for stuff like 5HP to be slightly faster though because that would make it even better in conjunction with horus and H dp and also maybe 2-3f less minus on block to really reinforce that it's a neat poke. 5MP is fine as is (this is such a fun button)

jMK is fantastic but imo could use a few more active frames (like 3 more to be precise) considering she not only brings out her hurtbox first but it's very easy to counter poke requiring really precise timing, it can still be precise but a little nudge doesn't hurt either.

Eliza lacks falling buttons, they become more and more relevant as the meta progress and while jLK would fit the bill it's kinda meh on that front. It could also stand to have less recovery or something because there are some heights you can't convert at all from. It'd be nice if it was more in line with the rest of the jLKs (a lot of them are like +6 or something and I'm just looking at the other air dashers)

5LP still has that really dumb nerf where it sends the opponent up for some reason and should maybe be reverted finally after all these years

Sehkmet is probably fine, I still feel it's mostly combo fodder but what can you do?

It would be nice if LoS could do a dunk or something as an option to just convert more easily for the cast or make the last hit 0 damage and the total be everything before it that way every character can more easily use her cool damage super.

Throne could use more tweaking for its anti zoning properties (maybe it can absorb 1 projectile while going through the rest idk, maybe better combo-abilty or some type of secondary advantage for it hitting from fullscreen, not quite a combo but maybe the ability to position better) and maybe 2HK could use more speed going forward but not to the point where she can just L spiral for safety but something similar to Testament 2H (maybe slower, that move goes far, I just want her to be able to hDP counter more often from this.)

This way you lean more into how poke-y she is, I'd like her to be more poke-y. I don't feel this would be homogenizing the character but more leaning to her strengths, which imo is her mid range poking game.

At least for me what it boils down to why I don't bother with eliza is that her frame data is not the greatest and could use some tweaks, I think she can maintain her difficulty while still being much more consistent fwiw. That's just me tho, I'm not very good at Eliza and I'm not exactly a pro either but I do think she's a very interesting character and I wish I could play her but at least to me, she feels really inconsistent. Which sucks for me because I think H spiral is really fun for chip teams and her poking game is by far one of the funnest I've used.

I don't think she's necessarily bad fwiw but I still feel there's a clear gap between eliza and sg. At least for me, it's not about messing up and losing being bad moreso how often messing up can happen compared to the rest of the cast. I still swear Eliza is rocket science. I could just be bad though, I could be using her incorrectly as well but I thought I'd toss my two cents even though nobody asked lol.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Nuuance and Yatoto
Eliza also hard struggles against zoners while having the least utility in the game, and imo she actually has the beowulf problem where she just needs to have a neutral assist, which isn't necessarily a bad thing but I'm just saying when there's more of the cast that's more inherently useful than eliza, that's a problem that should be fixed.
Disagree. Eliza is fine versus zoners. She fails versus fukua and robo specifically because she can't reach them with the hitboxes that go down on her (l fireball, in the air l beam. Startup of horus is slow, eliza is huge. If someone zones her from the sky she fails. I know because i played a lot versus 2 of the best parasoul players in europe and the best fukua player europe. anything that generally moves down into her huge forehead messes her up).
I have my fair share of experience versus peck, ratbaby, sanji and other notable zoners. Eliza generally isn't bad against zoning. You just need to put in extra effort to get the most out of her tools and understand how her startup + distance works. The only thing making her HORRIBLE in some zoning is her size, like i just explained.

Eliza lacks falling buttons, they become more and more relevant as the meta progress and while jLK would fit the bill it's kinda meh on that front. It could also stand to have less recovery or something because there are some heights you can't convert at all from. It'd be nice if it was more in line with the rest of the jLKs (a lot of them are like +6 or something and I'm just looking at the other air dashers)
Agree. Besides that she's super huge. Doesn't make sense in a game like skullgirls to not give a character falling buttons to get out of things (bigband has timpani and falling buttons too :( :( ). Besides that, unlike other skullgirls characters, eliza does not get to use her meter to get out of combos unless it level 3 which is very susceptible to projectiles falling down (like chair)
5LP still has that really dumb nerf where it sends the opponent up for some reason and should maybe be reverted finally after all these years
You can use this for sekh 50/50 sideswitches and crossunders.
Sehkmet is probably fine, I still feel it's mostly combo fodder but what can you do?
Sekhmet is great for footsies and midrange rps. Sekhmet also shits on teams that bruteforce (think beo/band/bella). Sekhmet is great verses zoning too if you understand startup and distance ( 2HK cancel into Butchers often stuffs teams with brass )
Throne could use more tweaking for its anti zoning properties (maybe it can absorb 1 projectile while going through the rest idk, maybe better combo-abilty or some type of secondary advantage for it hitting from fullscreen, not quite a combo but maybe the ability to position better) and maybe 2HK could use more speed going forward but not to the point where she can just L spiral for safety but something similar to Testament 2H (maybe slower, that move goes far, I just want her to be able to hDP counter more often from this.)
I really do not think anything is wrong with throne. I think people just don't know how to use throne. But that's fine. I agree that it could have 1 hit of zoning armor but eliza already has a lot of tools to deal with zoning by just eating projectiles with 2hk then instantly cancelling into throne, albus, horus or butchers..its very strange that I don't see people use this except for a few eliza players i've coached throughout the years. 2hk really exists to eat projectiles BEFORE you can counter things. you do not use it point blank or finish the entire animation of 2hk. Thats not how it works.
If anything, i'd wish for projectile armor to exist with 2hk even earlier. The only thing stopping eliza from doing it sometimes is projectiles hitting her huge head.
Have always been a firm believer that the only thing stopping eliza from being an absolute menace to zoners (which she already is) is her head hitbox and how slow 2hk projectile armor startup is.

At least for me what it boils down to why I don't bother with eliza is that her frame data is not the greatest and could use some tweaks, I think she can maintain her difficulty while still being much more consistent fwiw.
Eliza is in limbo. No idea what the original dev wanted to do with her. Her midrange is amazing, but its not something that fits into skullgirls. She has "skullgirls pokes" and is able to stick on you...but filia does it better. fortune does it better.
It's why i generally play eliza as a sit and wait character (unless my opponent does the same) i'd like it if her midrange options were tweaked even more (already happened with sekhmet which is awesome) but at the same time, i think it would make her even less of a skullgirls character lol.
At this point I just accepted that she's some wicked creature that can not be understood as simple as jump in jlp.
I genuinely do not have any issues with her except for the 1 mistake into death situation with her. And i'm someone who has played eliza and not dropped her since 2015
It's good that her health system is now also a resource to play around with. 2x nekbite enders on dead enemies give you a lot of health which means you can kind of make slightly more mistakes (for example) so your entire gameplan is to figure out how to get as much as health as possible from an almost dead opponent (or just eat > distance > make the timer go down)

TL'DR eliza is fine and only needs a buff for her 2hk. shes hard to play because despite her having ok sticky rushdown, its not the best out of the cast. She's hard to understand because she's more than just her combos and pressure and plays the game a bit different. And that is fine. I don't have trouble with this character, and I don't think people who don't understand this character should be asking for buffs. she is really really fine.
 
Coming back to this after playing mostly annie since the patch dropped.

jMP nerf still feels absolutely awful and my least favorite change. It killed some corner carry stuff when you catch 2 characters midscreen and losing combo routes into 6MP just kind of sucks. I'd honestly like a full hitstun revert but I would still be ok if it just got enough back for 6MP to work but not allow linking into jLP/jLK.

Still think pillar nerfs were justified and it's still good after the nerfs.

HK knuckle assist feels really bad and not worth using anymore. If the nerf was because they felt it was too good then the nerf worked. She still has other good assists so it's not the end of the world but even as someone that didn't use HK knuckle, I didn't think the nerf was even needed. Having multiple good assist options on a characters expands potential team comps which is always a plus imo.

Damage nerfs felt pretty negligible tbh.

Would like to see dash nerf reverted personally; it makes picking up from stuff that shouldn't be difficult kind of clunky feeling.

I feel like I'm probably one of the few people that regularly goes for star power. There's some cool reset potential within it and 1 reset in a 3v3 usually leads to death. With that being said, I still think the nerf to the 2nd jHP is kind of arbitrary because jHP adc jMP covers a very similar scenario anyway.

I still wish star power had a little more spice to it. Granted she doesn't need buffs and all of these suggestions are technically buffs, but it would definitely make install more appealing.
- Leave access to other supers during star power
- Have ground/air throw bounce them up higher and closer
- Enhance specials ala sol's dragon install. Have knuckle be a powerful wall bounce, have 3rd hit of divekick slam them into the ground and bounce them up, give crescent cut more hitstun, have DP come back down with jHK on hit. (I really wish I had some sort of way to mod the game just to see what these would look like in particular)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DoubleOrNothing
Annie install j.HP iad j.HP nerf during star power, was this really that bad? I never saw an issue with it since people could mash, what if j.HP install cost a bit more meter? Annie j.MP changes, for myself it made no sense, and it has
done nothing but make her feel bad. Losing j.MP into f.MP, j.MP > j.LP/LK reset, it's just getting rid of options to me. Knuckle changes to me feel unwarranted, if anything I'd at least ilke L. Knuckle to be +4 again. Annie doesn't
"suck" but I will say I do feel like someone drugged me when playing her.

Can we let Peacock keep the easier s.HP M > L George but make her teleports have about 5-7 frames of vulnerability at the start so people actually have a chance of hitting her for it? I always considered it too good of an escape with
how it is.

Headless Fortune Fiber no longer being grab invulnerable, this is a change for the sake of change. It's already negative on block, it having grab invulnerability isn't a big loss either way but I'm mostly doing it for mobility or
conversions if headless. So I honestly don't understand. I don't even know if I should want it back or not? It's just so odd to me. Fortune's hitboxes being bigger, honestly I'm fine with that only if for consistency's sake
Robo-Fortune gets the same treatment for her jumping hurtboxes. If you honestly wanted to nerf Fortune, it shoulda just been j.LK, and c.LK hitboxes and even then BARELY.

From things said:

Specials as assists, I get some moves needing to be tweaked as an assist. I don't have
a real problem against it, but if at some point it feels like a grocery/laundry list of
rules for someone to learn then I think then I'd consider that not only limiting but a form of failure.

I do agree with Stuff on the Big Band parry at the beginning of the forum.

I didn't realize Bella's point was that low when falling, that's ridiculous in comparison
to everyone else, thanks Dhoppler, and PME.
----

Fortune headless s.MP increase its lower hitbox downward slightly more so it may hit people better in the
corner, sometimes there are combos in the corner that when you wanna otg s.MP, it whiffs,
so this one is more of a QoL. I'm sure Sy and a few other Fortunes would agree that this normals whiffs more than it should in certain situations.

Cerebella j.HP buff it back to being high. It might just be me but after this nerf,
I never was as scared of her as I should be, and got rid of some of the fun mix
shenanigans people used to do to me with her. If anything what nerfs che deserved were
s.LK's hitbox, and Elbow (j2.MP) is cheeky. I never thought she deserved to lose it honestly.


Thanks for reading, feel free to destroy it.
 
I would like to see Double possibly getting some of her old changes reverted, so that she can better function as an assist/ utility character.
 
Very late response because I didn't play for like 3 months but yeah

No idea why the knuckle nerf happened, both dp and H cut were already better assists and now it feels like the game is just forcing you to not pick it. I already felt like it was a bit overnerfed way back when it both lost damage and started building 40 UD, but now it feels terrible to use every time, including on point since you can't even link mediums after it a lot of the time. L knuckle not being +4 is understandable but going all the way to -3 is pretty wild, also you can't confirm from 6hp with L knuckle midscreen now so the only use I can think for it on point is crossing under with an assist call which is pretty sad.

Pillar dhc being nerfed was definitely right, but it was also the only thing she needed to have changed, and the way it is now this move makes absolutely no sense on point. It was fine before and not even that strong compared to other lv2s, but now it's worse than many lv1s.

This jmp is the absolute worst, even basic routes now feel very tight and inconsistent, trying to convert from it is infuriating, and happy birthday routes might as well be impossible now. If the problem was linking into lights after then just make the recovery longer, the current version just makes me not wanna play the game.

The dash nerf makes it a little annoying to convert off throw and might be what's making the midscreen 6hp conversions impossible now. Also felt pretty unwarranted.

Fiber nerfs just feel kinda random, other than the head messing stuff up I can't think of anything right now that stands out about fortune that really needs toning down. If anything, headless damage can be very high, but even that's dependent on head positioning and you get very low damage a lot of the time so idk.

Also, PLEASE PLEASE change the input for fortune's taunt, I can't count how many times I've done iad jlk jhp slp slp and get taunt right on my opponent's face. Taunts were added in essentially as a joke for the main cast but this is extremely intrusive and annoying to deal with.

also would be very nice if double could be hit by any headless combos at all.
 
Also, PLEASE PLEASE change the input for fortune's taunt, I can't count how many times I've done iad jlk jhp slp slp and get taunt right on my opponent's face. Taunts were added in essentially as a joke for the main cast but this is extremely intrusive and annoying to deal with.
Getting accidental ms.Fortune taunt has gotten me killed too many times to count, so I would also like the inputs changed to something else.
 
I just think Eliza deserves a better dash speed, most of her approaches options are in the air, and with a better dash speed, her cLK and throw would be more threatening.

Some QoLs would be welcome as well, like auto-returning after LoS, Bite DHC, L Spiral xx sLK always hitting light characters, stuff like that.
 
also would be very nice if double could be hit by any headless combos at all.
For reference:

Last frame before double hits the ground

8dbe109514.jpg

Last airborne frame, Double hits the ground before decap even becomes active

3960d857fc.jpg


First decap active frame hitting otg

ce8336ee12.jpg


Also, it was mentioned already but headless smp is pretty small and inconsistent in general and it just whiffs sometimes and you die (theres a very recent clip somewhere of pme losing a happy birthday and being punished for smp dropping but I couldn't find it)
 
Last edited: